Authors: Liat Kimhi Chaim Zlotnikov Ilya Kuselman
Publish Date: 2006/10/05
Volume: 11, Issue: 11, Pages: 577-583
Abstract
A proficiency testing PT scheme is developed for comparability assessment of results of concrete slump and compressive strength determination The scheme is based on preparing of a test portion/sample of a concrete inhouse reference material IHRM at a reference laboratory RL in the same conditions for every PT participant Therefore in this scheme IHRM instability is not relevant as a source of measurement/test uncertainty while intra and betweensamples inhomogeneity parameters are evaluated using the results of RL testing of the samples taken at the beginning the middle and the end of the PT experiment The IHRM assigned slump and compressive strength values are calculated as averaged RL results Their uncertainties include the measurement/test uncertainty components and the components arising from the material inhomogeneity The test results of 25 PT participants were compared with the IHRM assigned values taking into account both the uncertainties of the assigned values and the measurement/test uncertainties of the participants Since traceability of the IHRM assigned values to the international measurement standards and SI units cannot be stated local comparability of the results is assessed It is shown that comparability of the slump and compressive strength determination results is satisfactory while uncertainty evaluation for slump results requires additional efforts
Keywords: