Authors: Gisela H Fontaine Kathrin Hametner Adolf Peretti Detlef Günther
Publish Date: 2010/10/22
Volume: 398, Issue: 7-8, Pages: 2915-2928
Abstract
Whereas colored andesine/labradorite had been thought unique to the North American continent red andesine supposedly coming from the Democratic Republic of the Congo DR Congo Mongolia and Tibet has been on the market for the last 10 years After red Mongolian andesine was proven to be Cudiffused by heat treatment from colorless andesine starting material efforts were taken to distinguish minerals sold as Tibetan and Mongolian andesine Using nanosecond laser ablation–inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry ICPMS the main and trace element composition of andesines from different origins was determined Mexican Oregon and Asian samples were clearly distinguishable by their main element content CaO SiO2 Na2O and K2O whereas the composition of Mongolian Tibetan and DR Congo material was within the same range Since the Li concentration was shown to be correlated with the Cu concentration the formerly proposed differentiation by the Ba/Sr vs Ba/Li ratio does not distinguish between samples from Tibet and Mongolia but only between red and colorless material Using femtosecond laser ablation multicollector ICPMS in highresolution mode laboratory diffused samples showed variations up to 3‰ for 65Cu/63Cu within one mineral due to the diffusion process Ar isotope ratio measurements proved that heat treatment will reduce the amount of radiogenic 40Ar in the samples significantly Only low levels of radiogenic Ar were found in samples collected onsite in both mine locations in Tibet Together with a high intrasample variability of the Cu isotope ratio andesine samples labeled as coming from Tibet are most probably Cudiffused using initially colorless Mongolian andesines as starting material Therefore at the moment the only reliable source of colored andesine/labradorite remains the state of OregonCu diffusion can be used to turn a plain colorless andesine into a red gemstone Cu and Ar isotope ratios in combination with main and trace elemental analysis can appoint andesine to thrie origin in Oregon Mexico and Asia In this study red andesines sold as coming from Tibet and Mongolia are revealed to be most probably Cudiffusion treatedProf Igor Villa from the Institute of Geology of the University in Bern is warmly thanked for access to and substantial help with the use of the noble gas spectrometer and argon data evaluation In addition his comments suggestions and critical remarks to general and special aspects of the topic were greatly appreciated Prof George Rossman’s personal description of their Ar analysis procedure was very helpful in carrying out the experiments We thank Ken Scarratt of GIA Thailand for providing diffusiontreated andesine samples for this research project Dr John Emmet’s diffusion treatment of our samples from Mongolia—carried out at his own cost and a key experiment for the interpretation of our data—is highly valued We thank those companies that helped by supplying samples organizing the expedition to Tibet and being interested in the outcome of the research whatever it may be It was a very important clarifying field expedition and an experience unique of its kind Dr Joachim Koch Dr Helmar Wiltsche and Reto Glaus are thanked for software and hardware support with the laser system
Keywords: